Politics
Texas Execution of Reinaldo Dennes Was Botched, Reverend Says
A reverend who witnessed the execution of Reinaldo Dennes says the condemned man screamed that his leg was 'on fire' and took far longer than usual to lose consciousness, while Texas prison officials deny the procedure was botched.
HUNTSVILLE, Texas â A spiritual adviser who stood inside the Texas death chamber during the execution of Reinaldo Dennes on Thursday night said the lethal injection was botched, describing a scene of prolonged suffering that state prison officials flatly deny.
Rev. Jeff Hood, who said he has witnessed a dozen executions by lethal injection, told reporters Friday morning that he knew something was wrong the moment he entered the chamber. He said Dennes had an intravenous line inserted in his neck â a placement Hood called abnormal â as well as a line in his foot, and visible marks suggesting multiple attempts to find veins in his arms.
"Immediately, Reinaldo began to scream, 'My leg! My leg! My leg is on fire!'" Hood said. He described Dennes writhing against the leather restraints and saying twice that the process was not working as intended. According to Hood, Dennes remained conscious for at least five minutes after the drugs began flowing, far longer than the typical under-a-minute onset.
An Associated Press reporter, Michael Graczyk, who has witnessed nearly 500 executions, also described a procedure unlike any he had seen, writing that Dennes' demeanor changed almost immediately and that he moaned and shouted about pain in his right leg.
The Texas Department of Criminal Justice, which carries out executions, rejected the accounts. Spokesperson Amanda Hernandez said the agency followed its protocols and that the overall process took about an hour, which she called not atypical. Hernandez said staff took time to place IVs in viable veins in the left foot and the left side of the neck, and that Dennes' complaints of pain began before any drugs were administered â and concerned his right leg, where no IV had been established. She said the lethal dose began at 6:52 p.m. and Dennes was pronounced dead at 7:08 p.m., a timeline she described as consistent with other executions.
Dennes was sentenced to death for his role in a 1996 diamond heist in Houston that left jeweler Janos Szucs dead. According to a U.S. Supreme Court document, Dennes planned the robbery from inside the Richmond Avenue building where Szucs worked, enlisting his brother and paying a cleaning employee with whom he was having an affair, Estrella Martinez, $5,000 for after-hours access. He had silencers made in his jewelry workshop and tested them before the crime.
On the evening of Jan. 24, 1996, Martinez opened a loading dock door and created distractions for security guard David Copeland, who was shot and wounded but survived by playing dead. Szucs was later found shot five times in his locked office; his safe was empty, with an estimated $3.6 million in diamonds, a five-carat pinky ring and $200,000 in cash missing â a haul worth more than $7.5 million today.
The dispute over Dennes' final minutes adds to a long-running debate over lethal injection in Texas, which adopted the method in 1977 and carried out the nation's first such execution in Huntsville in 1982. For opponents of capital punishment, the conflicting accounts underscore what they call the state's refusal to acknowledge suffering inside its death chamber. State officials maintain the execution was carried out properly.