Politics
Justice Department Concedes Austin Man Deported to Mexico Is a U.S. Citizen, Seeks Dismissal of His Lawsuit
Federal attorneys acknowledged Friday that Brian Jose Morales Garcia, an Austin man removed to Mexico after a Texas traffic stop, is a dual U.S.-Mexican citizen, while asking a judge to dismiss his claims that agents coerced him into leaving. Morales Garcia, who was allowed to return in August, alleges he was threatened and forced to sign deportation papers.
Federal attorneys acknowledged in court filings Friday that an Austin man removed to Mexico after a Texas traffic stop is a U.S. citizen, even as they asked a judge to dismiss his lawsuit against federal officials.
The Justice Department filing states that Brian Jose Morales Garcia "is a dual citizen of the United States and Mexico." The concession comes more than seven months after Morales Garcia, 25, was deported on April 7, 2026, following a traffic stop near Fredericksburg.
According to court documents, a Texas Department of Public Safety trooper stopped a vehicle in which Morales Garcia was a passenger on April 3. Officers contacted immigration authorities after he could not provide identification. Morales Garcia was born in Denver and raised in Mexico before moving to Austin.
His lawsuit alleges that while in custody he was coerced into signing deportation papers. He claims agents threatened him with imprisonment and forced him to falsely state that he had entered the country illegally. The government maintains that Morales Garcia voluntarily agreed to return to Mexico and denies that he was threatened or coerced.
In the Friday filing, government attorneys said an agent relied on Mexican records listing a Mexican birthplace and on statements they say Morales Garcia made. The complaint, meanwhile, alleges that family and friends tried to deliver his original citizenship documents and were refused.
Shortly after his removal, the Department of Homeland Security disputed his citizenship claim in a written statement, saying its agents "did NOT arrest a U.S. citizen" and that Morales Garcia had admitted he was a Mexican national who entered the country illegally.
Morales Garcia was permitted to reenter the United States on Aug. 30, nearly five months after being sent to Mexico. The motion says lawyers for both sides worked together to gather information about his birthplace and negotiated his return.
Federal attorneys are now asking the court to dismiss Morales Garcia's claims against federal officials and agents. His lawsuit also brings separate claims against unidentified DPS officers and Gillespie County sheriff's deputies. He is seeking an undisclosed amount of money.
The case has drawn attention to the consequences of immigration enforcement actions that critics say can ensnare U.S. citizens, particularly in a state where local police increasingly cooperate with federal immigration authorities. For Morales Garcia, the government's acknowledgment marks a formal reversal of its earlier position, though the legal fight over whether his removal was coerced continues.