Politics
Cornyn Blocks Trump Judicial Nominee Elliot Gaiser Over Texas Ties and Vetting
Sen. John Cornyn will not return the blue slip for Elliot Gaiser, President Trump's pick for a North Texas federal judgeship, citing Gaiser's lack of Texas residency, trial experience, and thorough vetting. Cornyn instead backs Fort Worth lawyer Steve Fahey as time runs short before Democrats take control of Congress.
WASHINGTON â Sen. John Cornyn announced Wednesday that he will not advance President Donald Trump's nominee for a federal judgeship in North Texas, dealing a likely fatal blow to Elliot Gaiser's confirmation prospects before Democrats assume control of Congress in January.
Cornyn, the outgoing Republican senator, said he has not returned the "blue slip" for Gaiser and does not intend to. The blue slip is a longstanding Senate tradition that gives home-state senators effective veto power over federal judicial nominees from their state.
"We have constitutional responsibilities, as you know, of advice and consent," Cornyn told reporters in Washington. "This is a lifetime job, and I'm just not going to rubber-stamp somebody that the White House drops in who's not from Texas, who has no trial experience, and who hasn't been thoroughly vetted by the bipartisan committee that Sen. Cruz and I created."
Gaiser currently leads the Justice Department's Office of Legal Counsel. His nomination was received in the Senate and referred to committee on Nov. 16. According to the Associated Press, he was first contacted about the role by Sen. Ted Cruz's staff on Nov. 4.
The vacancy is in the Northern District of Texas, where Judge Jane Boyle announced on Oct. 1 that she would take senior status. The seat covers a swath of North Texas including Fort Worth and surrounding communities, and the lifetime appointment could shape federal rulings on civil rights, environmental regulations, and corporate accountability for decades.
Cornyn said the White House has requested information on his preferred candidate, Fort Worth lawyer Steve Fahey. Fahey worked in the U.S. Attorney's Office for the Northern District of Texas from 2003 to 2021, then became a partner at Kirkland and Ellis in Dallas before starting his own practice.
The refusal to advance Gaiser underscores a rare break between a Republican senator and the Trump White House over judicial personnel. With Democrats set to take control of the Senate in January, Cornyn's decision effectively leaves the seat open for the incoming majority to fill â or for the White House to renominate a candidate with stronger Texas credentials.
For North Texas communities, the fight over the bench is not abstract. Federal judges in the Northern District hear cases involving immigration enforcement, labor disputes, environmental permits, and voting rights. A nominee without trial experience or deep local ties, critics say, may be less equipped to handle the district's heavy and complex docket.
Cornyn's move also signals that the Senate's blue-slip tradition remains a powerful tool even as partisan tensions over judicial confirmations have escalated. By withholding the slip, Cornyn has effectively blocked Gaiser without a formal vote, leaving the White House to decide whether to withdraw the nomination or risk a standoff.
The White House did not immediately respond to a request for comment. A spokesperson for Cruz did not respond to questions about whether he supports Gaiser's nomination or would return his own blue slip.
Fahey, Cornyn's preferred pick, did not respond to a request for comment. His biography on his former firm's website describes nearly two decades as a federal prosecutor in North Texas, including work on white-collar crime and public corruption cases.
With the clock ticking toward the new Congress, the vacancy on the Northern District bench remains unfilled â and the decision now rests with a White House that must weigh whether to push a controversial nominee or heed the home-state senator's objections.