Local
Texas Data Center Rules Could Deepen 'Sacrifice Zones' in Southern Dallas, Advocates Warn
As Texas weighs new rules for data centers, residents of Joppa and Red Oak fear regulations could concentrate more facilities in neighborhoods already burdened by industrial development, while state grid studies and a Dallas zoning debate loom.
DALLAS â As Texas lawmakers and regulators prepare new rules for the state's booming data center industry, community advocates in southern Dallas County are warning that the regulations could have an unintended consequence: pushing even more facilities into neighborhoods that have long shouldered the burden of industrial development.
In Joppa, a historic Freedman's town founded in the 1800s by formerly enslaved people, residents say a small data center has already appeared about a quarter-mile from homes, adding a constant mechanical hum to an area that has spent decades fighting air pollution and heavy industry.
"Mmmmm ... just continuously going, that's what I hear," said Joppa resident Miriam Matthews, who said the sound carries at night. "It's noise pollution."
Emmanuel Davis, who leads the community group Justice for Joppa, said the new facility compounds long-standing frustrations. "Do we want Joppa to be a community, or do we want Joppa to be a wasteland?" Davis asked. "Now, to have that nagging humming noise, it's very appalling."
Davis worries more data centers could follow because Dallas has no specific zoning category for them, meaning they are currently allowed by right on most industrial or mixed-use land. Five City Council members are now calling for new city regulations, and a council committee is expected to take up the issue soon.
Matthews said her message to city leaders is simple: "Don't put any more in this area. Let this be our quota."
The concern extends beyond Dallas. About 10 miles south of Joppa, massive hyperscale data centers are rising in Wilmer, Lancaster and Red Oak â cities that, like Joppa, are predominantly Black and Hispanic. In Red Oak, nine data centers are already operating and more than a dozen others are in the planning stages.
"I'm surrounded by them at this point," said Red Oak resident Sergio Chapa, who questions how many more the area can absorb. "More data centers. How many can we fit in here?"
Red Oak Mayor Mark Stanfill said the development has brought benefits, telling investigators he hears from residents who "appreciate that we're developing responsibly while still capturing the benefits these projects bring." Local officials have said data center tax revenue is helping repair roads and lower taxes.
But Abre' Conner, who tracks data center development for the NAACP's Center for Environmental and Climate Justice, said under-resourced minority communities often have fewer tools to challenge unwanted projects. She described areas with existing industrial buildout as "sacrifice zones" and warned that new rules could deepen those patterns.
"What the concern is is us repeating those kinds of patterns of the past," Conner said. "We are going to just end up deepening those sacrifice zones, deepening the places where they already have been saying, we actually don't want any more industrial build-out in our community."
State regulators are weighing changes that could shape where the next wave of data centers connects to the grid. The Electric Reliability Council of Texas, which operates the state's power grid, has been conducting a study known as "batch zero" to determine how and where planned data centers can hook up. In August, Gov. Greg Abbott paused that process and directed ERCOT and the Public Utility Commission of Texas to also study the community impacts of projects in the pipeline before proceeding.
Beth Garza, who served five years as ERCOT's independent market monitor, said the review could shrink the list of projects. "If the data center doesn't respond to the request for information on the community impacts, they'll be out," Garza said. "So it could be that this batch zero size gets way down to a much more manageable number."
Garza said companies are already drawn to the corridor south of Dallas because of access to major power and internet lines, and it is too early to know whether ERCOT's process will lead to more clustering there. ERCOT did not directly answer whether its studies might encourage clusters, but a spokesperson said the agency is continuing to work with state leadership and the PUC, with both reports expected Dec. 10.
Gov.-elect Gina Hinojosa has called for a moratorium on data centers until the Legislature passes new rules. Some Red Oak residents met with Hinojosa during her campaign to ask for state limits on construction near homes. The Data Center Coalition, which represents the industry, said it looks forward to working with state and local leaders and communities as discussions continue.
For residents, the coming months offer several chances to weigh in. ERCOT and the PUC hold public comment sessions at their meetings, and when the Legislature convenes in January, public hearings are expected to give Texans a chance to tell lawmakers what they want.
Conner said the state's review must look beyond grid efficiency and take neighbors' concerns seriously. "There are ways that we can ensure that all of those communities are protected," she said.