Local
Judge Temporarily Bars Breakaway Methodist Congregation From Using Highland Park Church Name
A Dallas County judge has temporarily blocked a bishop-appointed United Methodist congregation from using the Highland Park United Methodist Church name after the historic Mockingbird Lane church, which voted to leave the denomination, alleged trademark infringement and donor confusion.
A Dallas County judge has temporarily barred a United Methodist congregation from using the name Highland Park United Methodist Church, siding with the historic Mockingbird Lane church that voted last month to leave the denomination and now says the name is causing confusion among donors and neighbors.
Judge Bridgett Whitmore issued the order Wednesday evening, restraining the bishop-sanctioned congregation from using the Highland Park United Methodist Church name or soliciting charitable contributions under it. The restriction runs until Dec. 2 unless extended.
The ruling does not prevent anyone from worshipping. "This Order does not restrain Plaintiff or any person from gathering for worship, or from operating a congregation under any non-infringing name," Whitmore wrote.
The dispute follows a split within the congregation. Highland Park Methodist Church, a megachurch of more than 15,000 members across from Southern Methodist University, held a vote Oct. 25 and 26 in which about 90% of the more than 4,700 ballots cast favored leaving the United Methodist Church. Church leaders said they had lost trust in the denomination and wanted local control over congregational affairs.
After the vote, Bishop Ruben Saenz Jr. of the Horizon Texas Annual Conference, the regional United Methodist body, established a separate congregation for members who wanted to remain with the denomination and appointed his chief of staff, the Rev. Andy Lewis, to lead it. The two congregations held inaugural Sunday services Nov. 1; about 100 people attended the United Methodist service, while the departing church said nearly 8,000 attended its services that weekend.
The Mockingbird Lane church then went to court seeking a temporary restraining order, arguing it still owns the rights to the name and that the new congregation was creating confusion about donations. It is seeking a permanent block on the name; a hearing on a temporary injunction is set for Dec. 2.
In an email to the congregation Wednesday night, Lewis called the ruling disappointing. "I remain undeterred in our mission to offer a United Methodist ministry and witness to the Highland Park community and beyond," he wrote. "There is an unmistakable flame of faith and commitment that is burning in our congregation, and this temporary setback will not snuff it out."
The conference said it remains committed to the congregation Lewis leads. "The line connecting the congregation to its beginnings in 1916 remains unbroken," it said in a statement. "We remain confident in our position and believe the courts will ultimately bring clarity to these matters."
The church council of Highland Park Methodist said Thursday it wishes its neighbors well. "We respect their right to worship and build a faith community under a name that does not infringe on our historic trademarks or create confusion within our community," the council said.
Lewis said the congregation will continue worshipping Sunday at 10 a.m. at Prothro Great Hall at Perkins School of Theology at SMU, across a parking lot from the Mockingbird Lane church. The congregation's website was shut down Thursday. "Since all of our online giving avenues and most ways of communicating have HPUMC branding, we may have to regroup a bit," Lewis told members.
The legal fight has roots in a broader schism in the United Methodist Church, during which thousands of congregations left the denomination over disagreements about same-sex marriage and gay and lesbian clergy. Highland Park church leaders said they amended corporate documents during that period of "discord" to protect the church; the conference contended the edits amounted to a quiet attempt to sever ties and gave improper power to the church council. The church disputed that characterization.
The church has also asked the court to dismiss the denomination's lawsuit, with a hearing scheduled for Dec. 7.