Local
Judge Grants Sole Custody to Caregivers of 8-Year-Old Venezuelan Girl Detained by ICE in Irving
A judge awarded sole custody to Allith Galaviz and Laura Mejia, the temporary caregivers of 8-year-old Barbara Chuecos Hidalgo, who was taken into ICE custody in Irving two weeks ago. The caregivers say the ruling lets them hire an immigration attorney to fight her deportation.
IRVING, Texas â A judge on Tuesday granted sole custody of an 8-year-old Venezuelan girl to the two caregivers who had been raising her, two weeks after U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement agents detained the child in Irving as the family drove her to school.
The ruling gives Allith Galaviz and Laura Mejia legal custody of Barbara Chuecos Hidalgo, a decision they say opens the door to hiring an immigration attorney to challenge her deportation.
"What I'm going to tell her tonight, I'm going to tell her congratulations, that she's officially mine, but she needs to come clean up her room," Galaviz said with a smile.
"I'm happy. I know she's going to be back," he said. "I'm not going to say I don't worry, because we're not leaving; we're doing everything we can, but just getting this notice, I'm 100% sure that we're going to get her back. Now that we have custody of Barbara, we can finally hire an immigration attorney to stop her deportation."
Barbara's bedroom, with its stuffed animals and posters, remains as she left it.
**The detention**
Galaviz recorded video of the encounter as ICE agents surrounded the family's car and demanded they open the door. In the footage, which has circulated widely online, Barbara can be heard saying in Spanish, "My mom treats me bad. I don't want to go with her," referring to her biological mother.
Galaviz's son was also in the car. After Galaviz refused to open the door, an agent smashed the window to reach the girl.
"She was very scared," Galaviz said. "Everything happened so fast, and with all the adrenaline, and they were grabbing me by the neck, trying to grab me out of the car."
ICE agents ultimately took Barbara. Days later, the family said she was transferred to a facility in Corpus Christi and placed with the Office of Refugee Resettlement. A spokesperson for the agency said it does not discuss individual cases.
"She was taken unjustly," Galaviz said.
**How Barbara came to the U.S.**
Barbara arrived from Venezuela with her mother and had been living with Galaviz and Mejia on and off for about two years, according to the family, who cited alleged neglect by the biological mother.
ICE officials said Barbara's mother was convicted earlier this year of driving while intoxicated with the child in the vehicle. Child protective services became involved, and the mother was later sentenced and taken into ICE custody. She was granted voluntary departure and chose to be deported with Barbara.
In a statement, ICE said that when a parent makes that choice, the agency "works to facilitate family reunification and removal together." The agency said that over several months Barbara's caregiver declined to cooperate with efforts to facilitate communication and assess potential reunification, and that officers acted in accordance with applicable law and policy with consideration for the child's safety and welfare. ICE added that decisions about a child's placement, welfare or custody rest with child-welfare and judicial authorities, not with ICE.
Galaviz disputes that account, maintaining that the family cooperated with ICE.
**What comes next**
Even with custody settled, Barbara remains in federal care. Galaviz said the ruling does not mean she can immediately leave the facility.
"It doesn't mean that we can already get Barbara out of the facility of where she's at," he said. "We still have to go through a process, and the process can take 3-4 months."
The case has drawn attention to how immigration enforcement intersects with state child-welfare proceedings â and to the question of whether a child placed with caregivers by a state system should be subject to removal with a parent who has lost day-to-day custody. For now, the family is focused on the months ahead and on bringing Barbara home.