Local
Darlie Routier Files New Appeal Citing DNA and Fingerprint Evidence Pointing to Unknown Suspect
Lawyers for the Rowlett mother on death row for the 1996 murder of her 5-year-old son say new forensic tests on a bloody sock, the murder weapon and a door point to an unknown male intruder. The appeal asks the Texas Court of Criminal Appeals to send the case back to a lower court for a hearing.
DALLAS â Darlie Routier, the Rowlett mother who has spent nearly three decades on Texas death row for the 1996 killing of her 5-year-old son, filed a new appeal Thursday arguing that recently developed forensic testing points to an unknown male intruder and undermines the state's case against her.
The filing, submitted to the Texas Court of Criminal Appeals, centers on DNA results from a bloody sock recovered in a nearby alley, new fingerprint testing on the murder weapon and a door inside the family's home, and a fresh interpretation of microscopic fiberglass strands that prosecutors once used to argue Routier staged the attack.
According to the appeal, DNA testing on the sock points to an unknown man. The defense says the new fingerprint analysis on the murder weapon and the door produced prints that match neither Routier nor her then-husband, Darin Routier, and instead point to an unknown suspect. The filing also contends that fiberglass strands found on the murder weapon â evidence the state used to support its staging theory â may have come from an investigator's fingerprint brush rather than from Routier.
"Darlie Routier has spent nearly 30 years on Texas death row for a crime someone else committed, and of which she was a victim," defense attorney Vanessa Potkin said in a statement. "There's a wealth of newly available forensic evidence that supports Ms. Routier's innocence and dismantles the false narrative the state used to wrongfully convict Ms. Routier. We also now know that the state suppressed exculpatory evidence and presented false testimony at trial."
Potkin said the defense is urging the Court of Criminal Appeals to remand the case to the district court so Routier can present the new evidence. The appellate court has not yet ruled on whether to send the case back.
Routier was convicted of capital murder in the death of Damon Routier. His 6-year-old brother, Devon, was also killed in the same attack, but prosecutors kept the two cases separate and did not pursue a second trial after the first conviction. The state argued that Routier killed her sons and then slashed her own neck in a staged assault. She has consistently maintained that an intruder broke into the family's home, killed both boys and wounded her before fleeing.
Routier's two previous appeals were rejected. Both focused on trial records and legal proceedings rather than new DNA evidence, making this filing the first to rest on fresh forensic testing.
The case has drawn national attention for decades, and the new filing raises questions about the reliability of forensic evidence used in capital prosecutions. For North Texas residents who have followed the case since the 1990s, the appeal represents the most significant challenge yet to a conviction that has kept Routier on death row for nearly 30 years.
Attempts to reach Drake Routier, Darlie's sole surviving son, and Darin Routier, her ex-husband who has said he believes she is innocent, were unsuccessful Thursday.