Local
Dallas Launches Audit of Violent Crime Data After Auditor Flags Possible Misreporting
Dallas City Auditor Rory Galter confirmed an investigation into whether the police department's reported crime statistics are inaccurate, prompting the City Council's Finance Committee to keep an audit in place. Council member Cara Mendelsohn wants the review to determine if crimes are being downgraded or reclassified, while police officials say any errors are limited.
Dallas officials are moving forward with an audit of the police department's crime reporting after the city auditor confirmed that possible inaccuracies had been identified in the data used to track violent crime.
City Auditor Rory Galter told city leaders on Tuesday that the scope of the potential errors is not yet known, but that the city should examine the issue. The concern surfaced during an entrance conference with the Dallas Police Department, according to an email from Galter's office.
The Dallas City Council's Finance Committee voted to keep the audit in place to ensure that crime statistics reported to the FBI are accurate. The audit language asks directly: "Are controls in place to ensure the crime statistics reported to the FBI are accurate?"
The review comes as Police Chief Daniel Comeaux has publicly touted a drop in violent crime in Dallas in recent months. Department officials who spoke to the council on Thursday said the potential inaccuracies are limited in scope.
Council member Cara Mendelsohn said she wants the audit to determine whether crimes are being downgraded or reclassified. "There is data to suggest there is an increase in a lower charge compared to a higher charge," Mendelsohn said.
Dallas Police Major Steve Bishop acknowledged that certain offenses, such as aggravated robberies, have been downgraded, but he described the issue as not extensive. "If that question was asked, we would welcome that question if it would allay the city council's fears, absolutely," Bishop said.
Mendelsohn said the audit should either disprove the problem or expose reporting failures that need to be fixed. "Now that we've had this robust public debate, I can't imagine us not having the audit because that would be us burying the issue," she said. "I can't imagine that the risk of exposing something bad would be overlooked so that we save face instead of get to the facts of the matter. That is what the audit should do: disprove a problem or show what the problems are so they can be fixed."
The audit is expected to be completed sometime during the city's current fiscal year. The findings could have significant implications for public safety policy and for how residents understand trends in violent crime across Dallas neighborhoods.