Local
Dallas County Jail's New Magistrate Rule Draws Pushback from 21 Police Chiefs Over Public Safety Fears
A policy requiring officers to bring arrestees before a magistrate before jail booking has sparked warnings from local police chiefs that violent offenders could be released back onto the streets, while the sheriff says she's simply following the law.
DALLAS â A new Dallas County Jail policy requiring law enforcement agencies to secure a magistrate's review before booking arrestees has ignited a dispute between the county sheriff and local police departments, with 21 police chiefs warning the rule could force them to release potentially violent offenders back onto the streets.
The change took effect Nov. 1, when the Dallas County Sheriff's Office began requiring agencies to present any arrested person before a county magistrate before they are admitted to the jail. The policy applies to Class B misdemeanors and above â offenses considered county matters. Previously, agencies brought arrestees directly to the jail, where they saw a Dallas County magistrate. Agencies with pre-existing agreements with the county for magistrate services are exempt.
The sheriff's office issued two forms that agencies can use to document that an arrestee appeared before a magistrate.
The policy has drawn sharp concern from local law enforcement, particularly when arrests are made on Dallas County warrants. In a Nov. 6 letter, 21 police chiefs in Dallas County said the rule could result in violent offenders being released.
"In these situations where DSO is rejecting arrested persons that have active DSO warrants, the cities are left with no options but to release the individual and reactivating their warrant," the chiefs wrote, adding that this puts "potentially violent felons back on the streets."
A separate letter signed by 14 law enforcement agencies called on the sheriff's office to review the procedure to ensure an "immediate, consistent process" for booking inmates.
"Multiple law enforcement agencies should not be placed in a position where they are expected to honor Dallas County warrants, make the requested arrests, and then assume responsibility for releasing those same individuals because of an administrative or contractual disagreement between government entities," that letter read.
Dallas Police Association President Sean Pease said he worries the rule will discourage agencies from making arrests on county warrants altogether. He noted that smaller departments cannot afford the cost of staffing a judge overnight or on weekends.
"Some smaller communities in Dallas County, they can't afford a $200,000 increase to have a judge working overnights, or another judge to be working on a weekend," Pease said. "It's just not feasible for them. So I just want to make sure the other option isn't they just release the individuals."
Dallas County Sheriff Marian Brown defended the policy, saying it is not driven by jail overcrowding or budget concerns but by a legal obligation to protect the rights of people who have been arrested.
"This was never an effort to create hardship for the agencies. It's simply something that is legal, something that has to be observed as a right of an individual who has been arrested," Brown said. "We put the letter here to remind people that if your person has not been magistrated, and when you bring them in here, they are subject to being turned away."
Brown pushed back on agencies that have threatened to release arrestees rather than comply.
"It's about doing what is right," she said. "Rather than do what is legal, make the arrest a good arrest, make it good all the way from start to finish, they would rather threaten to release people. I say shame on them."
The city of Carrollton has sued the Dallas County Sheriff's Office to block the policy, but a judge denied its request for a second time last week.
The dispute leaves local departments weighing whether to absorb new costs for magistrate services, turn to the courts, or release people arrested on county warrants â a prospect that has raised alarms about public safety across Dallas County.