Friday, November 20, 2026·Focal News

The Columbus Focal

Columbus's independent voice

Local

Hilltop Residents Push Back on 246-Unit Apartment Plan for Whitethorne Woods

Columbus Development Commission tables a proposal to build affordable housing on 20 wooded acres near Eakin Road after neighbors warn it would destroy a de facto nature preserve. The developer says it will preserve 4.5 acres and connect to a planned shared-use path.

Hilltop Residents Push Back on 246-Unit Apartment Plan for Whitethorne Woods

A proposal to build a 246-unit apartment complex on 20 acres of heavily wooded land near Eakin Road was tabled by the Columbus Development Commission last week after residents from the surrounding Hilltop neighborhood turned out to oppose it.

The site, part of a larger 50-acre tract known as Whitethorne Woods, was once envisioned as a nature preserve or park. The City of Columbus even secured a grant to help acquire the land, but negotiations with owner Ric Queen collapsed over price, with each side blaming the other. Queen later agreed to sell the 20-acre portion to Kittle Property Group, which is now seeking approval for the apartment development.

At the commission’s November 12 meeting, neighbor Emily Schwarz told members that clearing the woods for high-density housing would harm the community.

“Clearing 20 acres of natural woods for high-density housing threatens the unique charm and established character of our neighborhood,” Schwarz said. “The targeted site functions as a vital local nature preserve, providing critical urban canopy, wildlife habitats, and natural carbon sequestration.”

Other speakers raised concerns about children’s safety near a planned retention pond and about pedestrian access, noting that the complex’s entrance and exit would require travel on neighborhood streets without sidewalks.

Attorney Jack Reynolds and Brian Pozen, development director for Kittle Property Group, presented the site plan, which they said includes 4.5 acres set aside as a “tree protection area.” Pozen added that the complex would connect to a shared-use path the city plans to build along Eakin Road. He also said the company approached both the City of Columbus and Metro Parks about donating the 4.5-acre wooded portion, but both declined.

Queen, who attended the meeting, said he is still seeking a buyer for the adjacent 30-acre parcel and remains willing to sell it to the city for parkland.

Commission Chair Michael Fitzpatrick encouraged the developer to return with more details and to engage with neighbors. Other board members agreed, with one specifically citing the lack of a clear plan for safe pedestrian access as an unresolved issue.

“There’s a lot at stake…I would like to see further details,” Fitzpatrick said. “We’d appreciate if you go back to drawing board and maybe go to the neighbors and allay some of their concerns.”

Fitzpatrick acknowledged that the fate of the adjacent parcel and the earlier promise of a full 50-acre park fall outside the commission’s jurisdiction.

“I could understand that if I was a homeowner and I was expecting a park, and it was anything short of a park, I’d be disappointed,” he added. “So that paints the canvas in kind of a dark image.”

The commission’s decision to table the proposal means the developer must revise its plans and return for further review. The project comes as Columbus faces a growing demand for affordable housing, but residents argue that wooded urban land provides essential environmental benefits that cannot be replaced.

More from The Columbus Focal