Local
Federal Appeals Court Pauses Army's Plan to Detonate Five Tons of Lead Azide in Iowa
The U.S. Eighth Circuit Court of Appeals granted an emergency stay Friday, indefinitely halting the Army's plan to blow up five tons of unstable lead azide at the Iowa Army Ammunition Plant in Middletown. Environmental groups sued over the EPA's emergency permit, citing inadequate notice and undisclosed health evidence.
A federal appeals court on Friday indefinitely blocked the U.S. Army's plan to detonate five tons of unstable lead azide at a munitions plant in southeastern Iowa, granting an emergency stay hours before the explosion was set to occur.
The U.S. Eighth Circuit Court of Appeals issued a one-sentence administrative stay of the Environmental Protection Agency's emergency permit "until the emergency motion for stay is ruled upon by this court." The order came one day after the Iowa Environmental Council and the Sierra Club Iowa Chapter filed suit challenging the permit.
The detonation had been scheduled for noon Central Time Friday at the Iowa Army Ammunition Plant in Middletown, a community of about 360 people roughly four hours west of Chicago. The Army had already pushed the blast to Monday before the court intervened. Because the stay sets no new date, the delay is indefinite pending further court action.
The plant has stored 68 barrels of lead azideâa highly sensitive explosive used in munitions since World War Iâfor more than 20 years. The material, totaling about five tons, sits in earthen-covered containers in a bath of ethanol and water to keep it stable, according to Justine Barati, a public affairs specialist at Army Sustainment Command. A routine inspection earlier this year found that some of the water had evaporated.
According to the EPA, the lead azide deteriorated during storage, allowing it to recrystallize and become increasingly sensitive to friction and shock. That volatility raised the risk of an accidental explosion during storage or handling.
Acting Army Secretary Adam Telle said the military concluded that a "controlled detonation" was the safest way to dispose of the material. But the blast would have sent a plume of dust containing toxic lead particles into the air. Preliminary maps based on Friday's weather showed the plume potentially drifting north across eastern Iowa, over the Mississippi River and possibly into far northwestern Illinois.
Thousands of people live along the plume's projected path, and the area includes groundwater sources, river water and farmland. Because the toxic particles are expected to settle on surfaces, residents and local officials worried about lead contamination on agricultural land, residential properties, playground equipment and other outdoor areas.
Under the original plan, Middletown residents were asked to evacuate from 8 a.m. to 2 p.m. Friday. The Army also warned of possible damage to nearby buildings, including shattered windows.
The environmental groups argued that residents had extremely short notice to prepare and take safety precautions, and that the evidence the EPA used to determine the detonation was the best course of action had not been made public and therefore could not be evaluated.
A bipartisan group of elected officials from Illinois and Iowa had also urged the Pentagon and EPA to delay the blast and explore safer alternatives. In a letter to Telle and EPA Administrator Lee Zeldin, they wrote: "While we understand the urgent need to address these volatile materials, their detonation has the potential to spread lead contamination in and around the region. We call on you to consider delaying this detonation until there is an opportunity to explore safer alternatives."
The signatories included U.S. Sens. Dick Durbin and Tammy Duckworth of Illinois; U.S. Reps. Darin LaHood, Mary Miller and Eric Sorensen of Illinois; Illinois Gov. JB Pritzker; and U.S. Sen.-elect Juliana Stratton of Illinois and U.S. Sen.-elect Josh Turek of Iowa.
The case now returns to the Eighth Circuit, which will decide whether to extend the stay while the legal challenge proceeds. For residents of Middletown and surrounding communities, the ruling offers a reprieve from an evacuation order and the threat of airborne lead, but no permanent resolution.