Local
Cook County Judge Vacates Anthony Garrett's 1994 Murder Conviction in Dantrell Davis Killing, Orders Retrial
Circuit Judge Adrienne E. Davis ruled Monday that Anthony Garrett's handwritten confession to the 1992 killing of 7-year-old Dantrell Davis was likely coerced, overturning a conviction that has kept him imprisoned for more than three decades. The decision did not name retired Chicago Police Detective Richard Zuley, the interrogator at the center of the torture allegations.
A Cook County judge on Monday vacated the murder conviction of Anthony Garrett, finding that his handwritten confession to the 1992 killing of 7-year-old Dantrell Davis was more likely than not the product of torture.
Circuit Judge Adrienne E. Davis, reading from a 37-page ruling at the Leighton Criminal Courthouse, ordered Garrett's conviction and sentence set aside, suppressed the confession and directed that he be retried and transferred from state prison to the Cook County Jail.
Garrett, 68, appeared in a blue prison uniform as more than a dozen relatives and supporters in the gallery smiled and murmured during the hearing. He has been held at the Centralia Correctional Center and was not scheduled for release until 2039 under a 100-year sentence imposed after a jury convicted him in 1994.
Davis scheduled a Dec. 7 hearing on whether Cook County State's Attorney Eileen O'Neill Burke's office will appeal and on Garrett's detention status.
The ruling followed a monthslong evidentiary hearing that concluded with closing arguments in May. Garrett's lead attorney, Jennifer Blagg, argued that retired Chicago Police Detective Richard Zuley orchestrated her client's abuse in custody and tied the case to a pattern of coercion across a string of cases from 1987 to 2003, including four murder convictions that were later thrown out.
Blagg also drew a parallel between Garrett's interrogation and Zuley's work as a U.S. Naval reservist at Guantánamo Bay, Cuba. She called Mohamedou Ould Slahi, a former detainee held there for 14 years without charges, who testified by Zoom from Rotterdam last November that Zuley subjected him to months of torture in 2003. Slahi, 55, later wrote a memoir that became the basis for the 2021 film "The Mauritanian."
"The real Dick Zuley, I would submit to the court, is the one Mohamedou Ould Slahi saw," Blagg argued in May.
Prosecutors urged the judge to set aside allegations from other cases. Armando G. Sandoval called them "allegations, not findings" with "no connection to Garrett," and cautioned against treating Slahi's book or the film as objective. He also challenged Garrett's account of being beaten by two large men in sports jerseys while shackled to an eyebolt, noting testimony that Garrett was not limping afterward and that his description of the assault changed over the years.
Zuley, who was hired by the Chicago Police Department in 1970 and worked there for more than three decades, testified in February and April that he was unaware of anyone handcuffing Garrett to the eyebolt or abusing him. He said he left other detectives in charge overnight and that Garrett confessed the next morning to shooting at members of a rival gang near Dantrell, then signed a handwritten statement. Zuley told the court that threats and physical abuse were less reliable than "rapport building."
A 2023 finding by the Illinois Torture and Relief Commission described an "overwhelming" history of "lengthy and consistent" complaints alleging psychological and physical torture involving Zuley. Judges have vacated at least four murder convictions tied to him, involving Lathierial Boyd, Lee Harris, Carl Reed and David Wright.
Garrett's attorneys were blocked by the Trump administration from questioning Zuley about his Guantánamo work.
Dantrell was shot on Oct. 13, 1992, as he walked to school with his mother in Cabrini-Green, the former North Side public housing complex. Police said a sniper fired from an upper floor of a building.
Monday's ruling does not resolve the case against Garrett, who now faces the prospect of a new trial, but it undercuts a conviction that rested heavily on the disputed confession. For a city still reckoning with decades of contested interrogations, the decision adds another chapter to the long record of Chicago cases in which alleged coercion by detectives has undone guilty verdicts.