Local
Appeals Court Blocks Army's Plan to Detonate Tons of Lead Azide in Iowa
A federal appeals court has stayed the EPA permit allowing the Army to detonate five tons of unstable lead azide near Middletown, Iowa, leaving residents and officials scrambling as the Army warns of growing explosion risks.
A federal appeals court late Thursday put on hold a permit that would have allowed the U.S. Army to detonate several tons of a volatile bomb-making chemical in southeastern Iowa, throwing into doubt plans for an operation that had already been delayed once amid public outcry.
The 8th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals granted a request by environmental groups to stay the emergency permit approved earlier this month by the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency. The permit had cleared the way for the Army to destroy dozens of barrels of lead azide stored at the Iowa Army Ammunition Plant near Middletown, about 160 miles southeast of Des Moines.
âThe Army canât detonate under the permit while the permit is stayed,â said Thien Chau, an attorney with Earthjustice, which filed the petition on behalf of Iowa groups seeking a review of the permit.
The court had not issued a schedule as of Friday for when it might rule or whether it will hold a hearing. Chau said attorneys expect the court will try to decide before Monday, when the Army now plans to carry out the operation. He acknowledged the legal bar for blocking the detonation is high.
âYou have to show that there is no other possible safe alternative for treating this,â he said.
The Army had initially planned to detonate the material on Friday but announced Thursday it would push the operation to Monday after widespread public concern about potential health and environmental effects.
âThis will delay the detonation until the latest possible moment prior to a forecast temperature drop, which would risk further destabilization of the material,â Acting Army Secretary Adam Telle said in a post on X.
The Army, EPA and Department of Health and Human Services issued a joint statement Friday saying they were working to ensure the detonation is conducted as safely as possible.
âOfficials have been meticulously planning for this event since March, and all agencies involved are prepared to take the most extreme mitigation measures available to ensure there is no risk to the public and any disruptions are minimized,â the statement read.
Gov. Kim Reynolds activated the state emergency operations center Friday afternoon, saying Iowa agencies were coordinating with federal officials to monitor the situation and keep residents informed.
The trouble began in March, when staff at the ammunition plant discovered several dozen barrels of degraded lead azide, a chemical used in munitions production. Crystallization had made the material unstable and dangerous, prompting the Army to assemble experts in munitions chemistry, engineering and environmental safety to devise a disposal plan.
According to EPA documents, alternatives such as neutralizing and decomposing the drumsâ contents with other chemicals were considered. But officials said handling the drums would increase the probability of an accidental, fatal detonation.
The environmental groups disagreed, arguing in their petition that other alternatives were not fully considered and criticizing officials for not sharing more information with the public. The Army detailed its plans during a public meeting in Middletown in October, but a public advisory issued Sunday was the first time other communitiesâsome as far as 100 miles awayâbecame aware of the potential impact.
Nearly 400 people live in Middletown, but thousands more in surrounding areas could be affected by detonated material that could disperse in the air and settle on the ground. Some schools and businesses planned to close, and the Army recommended that people stay indoors, bring pets and livestock inside, and keep windows and doors closed. Officials also urged residents in the path of the predicted plume to clean cars, windowsills and outdoor surfaces afterward.
âThe detonation will result in an air plume with some lead-containing particles which will disperse in the air and deposit on the ground,â an advisory stated. âLead is toxic to humans and animals.â
Lucy Giehl, who lives about 4 miles north of the plant with her husband and two dogs, said Thursday she still didnât know whether she needed to wear gloves to wipe down surfaces or keep her dogs from drinking water in their pond.
âThereâs just so many details that I feel like havenât been addressed with the public,â she said.