Wednesday, November 18, 2026·Focal News

The Charlotte Focal

Charlotte's independent voice

Local

Suspect in 2024 Shelby homicide arrested days after reward raised to $8,000

Jonathan Martzes Petty, 42, was taken into custody Monday, more than two years after Timothy Ruff was shot and killed in Shelby. The arrest came three days after police boosted the reward for information in the case.

Suspect in 2024 Shelby homicide arrested days after reward raised to $8,000

SHELBY, N.C. — A man accused in a 2024 Shelby homicide is in custody after more than two years on the run, authorities said, an arrest that followed a last-ditch push by investigators to draw out new leads with a bigger cash reward.

Jonathan Martzes Petty, 42, was arrested Monday, Nov. 16, according to the Cleveland County Sheriff's Office. He had been wanted on charges of murder and possession of a firearm by a felon in the death of Timothy Ruff, who was shot and killed on March 29, 2024.

Shelby police and federal agents had searched for Petty for more than two years. On Nov. 13, three days before the arrest, police announced they had raised the reward to $8,000 for information leading to his capture.

Authorities have not said how Petty was located. In announcing the increased reward, police said any information shared with investigators would be kept confidential and that tipsters would remain anonymous.

It was not immediately clear whether Petty will face additional charges related to the yearslong search.

The case had remained open since Ruff's killing, with Petty identified early as a suspect but eluding capture. The reward increase marked a renewed effort to generate leads from the public before Monday's arrest.

Petty's arrest brings a measure of closure to a case that has hung over the community for more than two years, though questions remain about the circumstances of his capture and what comes next in the legal process. Court records and further details on his initial appearance were not immediately available.

More from The Charlotte Focal