Friday, November 20, 2026·Focal News

The Charlotte Focal

Charlotte's independent voice

Local

Insurer Moves to Avoid Payout in Zarutska Lawsuit, Potentially Shifting Liability to City

StarStone Specialty Insurance Co. has filed a federal lawsuit arguing it should not have to cover expenses tied to the wrongful-death suit over Iryna Zarutska's fatal stabbing on the Lynx Blue Line, citing the security contractor's failure to report earlier violent incidents. If the insurer prevails, Charlotte taxpayers could be left covering any damages.

Insurer Moves to Avoid Payout in Zarutska Lawsuit, Potentially Shifting Liability to City

A private security contractor on duty the night of last year's fatal stabbing on the Lynx Blue Line could lose its insurance coverage under a new federal lawsuit, a development that could leave the City of Charlotte responsible for any damages awarded in the victim's wrongful-death case.

StarStone Specialty Insurance Co., based in Ohio, filed suit in federal court earlier this month arguing it should not have to cover legal costs, settlements or judgments connected to the wrongful-death lawsuit filed by the estate of Iryna Zarutska, who was fatally stabbed on the light rail system last year.

The insurer's central claim is that Professional Police Services, the security contractor for the Charlotte Area Transit System, failed to promptly report three violent incidents on the CATS system that later gave rise to lawsuits — including the attack that killed Zarutska.

Under the terms StarStone cites, that failure to report the earlier incidents would relieve the insurer of its obligation to cover the claims.

The stakes extend well beyond the contractor. If StarStone succeeds in avoiding coverage, Professional Police Services could be left without insurance to pay for its defense or any judgment in the wrongful-death case. That, in turn, raises the prospect that the city — which contracted with the firm to guard the transit system — could be forced to absorb the financial fallout.

The dispute also draws new attention to how violent incidents on the CATS system were handled and reported in the period before Zarutska's death, and to the oversight of the private firm hired to keep riders safe.

The case is pending in federal court.

More from The Charlotte Focal