Local
Family Demands Answers After 26-Year-Old Dies One Day After Booking Into York County Jail
Cody Middleswart, 26, was booked on a shoplifting charge Friday and found unconscious in his cell Saturday night; his family wants to know how he died, and SLED is investigating the second inmate death at the facility this year.
YORK COUNTY, S.C. â The family of a 26-year-old man who died at the York County Detention Center over the weekend is pressing for answers, describing his death as a shock and questioning how he could have died so soon after being booked.
Cody Middleswart was booked into the jail on Friday, Nov. 13, on a shoplifting charge, according to the York County Sheriff's Office. Just before 7 p.m. the following day, detention officers found him unconscious and not breathing. Emergency medical crews arrived minutes later and transported him to a local hospital, where he was pronounced dead shortly before 8 p.m.
The sheriff's office has described the death as following a medical emergency. The South Carolina Law Enforcement Division, the state's primary investigative agency, confirmed it is continuing to investigate.
It is the second inmate death at the facility this year, a fact that adds weight to the family's calls for transparency.
For Middleswart's cousin, Leonard Dunning, the loss is deeply personal. He recalled a childhood spent together â trips to the lake, video games, shared memories â and a cousin he describes as fun to be around.
"It was shocking. It was really shocking. I didn't expect my cousin to pass so soon," Dunning said.
Dunning said the circumstances of the death do not add up for him, given that Middleswart was in a facility with detention officers and other people nearby.
"It just doesn't make any sense at all especially if you have other guards around, other people, other cellmates," he said. "It just doesn't, it doesn't make any sense."
Middleswart leaves behind a daughter. Dunning said the family is struggling with the loss and wants to understand what happened inside the detention center as they seek closure.
"He always had a good heart. Even you know when he was on his bad path, he always had a big heart," Dunning said.
The death raises familiar questions about oversight and medical response inside local jails. In South Carolina, SLED routinely investigates deaths of people in custody, and the findings can inform whether policies or staffing at a facility need review. For families, the investigation is often the only window into what happened in the hours before a loved one died.
As of Wednesday, no further details about the medical emergency or the circumstances leading up to it had been released. The family's account and the sheriff's office timeline leave key questions unanswered: what prompted the medical crisis, how quickly staff responded, and whether anything could have been done differently.
The investigation is ongoing.