Wednesday, November 18, 2026·Focal News

The Boston Focal

Boston's independent voice

Politics

Suffolk Superior Court Judge Weighs Whether Senate Must Turn Over Records in Massachusetts Audit Fight

A Suffolk Superior Court judge heard arguments Tuesday over whether the Massachusetts Senate has fully complied with Auditor Diana DiZoglio's requests for four sets of records tied to the voter-approved legislative audit. The Senate says the case is moot; DiZoglio says it is more stalling, and a December hearing will take up the House's constitutional challenge.

Suffolk Superior Court Judge Weighs Whether Senate Must Turn Over Records in Massachusetts Audit Fight

A Suffolk Superior Court judge on Tuesday pressed both sides in Auditor Diana DiZoglio's lawsuit seeking to force the Massachusetts Senate to turn over four sets of documents, a dispute the Senate says is moot because it has already provided the records.

Associate Justice David Deakin questioned the Senate's argument first. Jennifer Grace Miller, representing the Senate, told the court that "the auditor's not entitled to additional relief, and we believe the case is moot." Deakin responded, "It seems to me that you can't have your cake and eat it too."

Attorneys for DiZoglio then argued that the Senate is mischaracterizing what is at stake. "The Senate is characterizing them as audits, and we're saying they're not audits," said Shannon Liss-Riordan, representing the auditor. Deakin also asked what further discovery would be needed to answer the narrow question of whether the Senate had fully complied.

The lawsuit is the latest front in DiZoglio's long-running effort to audit the Legislature, an authority voters endorsed in 2024 when 72% backed a ballot measure on the issue. DiZoglio argues the Senate's resistance is another example of stalling a measure with broad public support.

Deakin indicated he would likely rule on summary judgment and scheduled a Dec. 2 hearing at which the House will present its constitutional arguments. DiZoglio said after the hearing that the constitutional question is the central issue. "My issue of concern is to get a ruling on the constitutionality," she said. "The only reason we're discussing these four limited records requests is only because that's all the attorney general would allow for us to argue."

Senate President Karen Spilka issued a statement after the hearing saying the Senate had shown it voluntarily provided all the specific documents the auditor requested. "While the Auditor insists on prolonging a legal fight over information that the Senate already makes publicly available, the Senate remains focused on lowering costs for residents, pushing back on the harmful actions of the Trump Administration, and expanding opportunities here in Massachusetts," Spilka said.

The case remains before Suffolk Superior Court, with the December hearing set to weigh the House's constitutional challenge to the audit authority voters approved.

More from The Boston Focal