Politics
Quincy Golf Course Lease Extension Ignites Beacon Hill Budget Fight
A last-minute amendment in the state budget would extend the private operators' lease on publicly owned Granite Links golf course by 50 years, bypassing competitive bidding and lease-length laws. Quincy's mayor backs the deal, but the state senator and newly elected city councilors are demanding an audit and questioning the influence of lobbyists and campaign donations.
A long-simmering dispute over control of the publicly owned Granite Links golf course in Quincy has erupted on Beacon Hill, where House lawmakers have tucked a provision into a multibillion-dollar budget closeout bill that would extend the current operators' lease by half a century.
The amendment, inserted last month, would grant Quarry Hills Associates an additional 50 years on top of its remaining 30-year lease, pushing the arrangement to 2106. It also waives two state laws: one that limits leases of public land to 30 years and another that requires competitive bidding for municipal property.
Supporters say the extension is needed to finance improvements, including a hotel and more parking, that would boost revenue for the city. Critics argue the maneuver sidesteps the legislative process and locks in a sweetheart deal for a private operator on land that belongs to the public.
At the center of the fight are two brothers-in-law who once worked together in Quincy City Hall: Mayor Tom Koch, a seven-term Democrat who backs the extension, and state Sen. John Keenan, who has raised sharp questions about the deal and is pressing for an audit of the existing lease.
"When I look at this, I don't like it," Keenan said. "I don't like what I see. I think there needs to be more work done to determine whether it's a sweetheart deal or a fair deal."
Koch, who was a young City Hall aide when the original deal was brokered in 1992, called the existing arrangement "phenomenal" for Quincy. He said the city has received athletic fields, open space, and a share of revenueâ10% of gross golf revenue and 10% of net hospitality revenueâwhile the developers invested tens of millions of their own dollars.
"People have the right to have their opinion, of course, and the right to question and get answers, absolutely," Koch said. "But I think this is a good thing for the city of Quincy. It has been from day one, and I'd like to see it continue."
According to Quarry Hills, the course employs 500 full- and part-time workers and has sent $11.6 million to the city since opening in 2003. The company's president, Thomas O'Connell, declined an interview request but pointed to a letter to the editor in the Quincy Sun, in which he wrote that the extension is necessary to build a hotel and additional parking.
"Without additional investment, revenues are expected to plateau as facilities age and physical constraintsâsuch as limited parkingâremain unresolved," O'Connell wrote. "Another operator might be content to continue operations as they are and ride out the remaining lease term. As the developers responsible for the vision and execution of Quarry Hills, we see an opportunity to do more."
Quarry Hills has hired former state Rep. Brian Dempsey, a onetime House Ways and Means chairman, as a lobbyist. Several people connected to the business have also donated to Beacon Hill leaders: Walter Hannon, the general manager at Granite Links, gave to Senate President Karen Spilka's campaign for the first time this year, and at least three others who work for a business with ties to the course each gave the maximum $1,000 in a single day in May, according to campaign finance records.
The proposal has also roiled Quincy politics. In 2024, the City Council approved a home-rule petition for a similar extension, and the House backed it in 2025, but it remains stuck in a Senate committee. After that council vote, voters swept out several Koch-friendly incumbents and elected new members who have taken a more combative stance toward the mayor. Earlier this month, the council voted to support Keenan's call for an audit and passed a resolution opposing the budget amendment.
Councilors have pointed to Falmouth as a model. The Cape Cod town recently held a competitive bidding process for its 27-hole country club and awarded a 10-year lease that one Quincy councilor said will bring in more revenue than Quincy's arrangement because Falmouth collects money from golf cart rentals and land taxes.
The land beneath Granite Links was once a landfill and granite quarry before 13 million tons of dirt from the Big Dig were trucked in to reshape it. Tom Palmer, a 70-year-old Milton resident who has long pushed for more walking access to the Blue Hills through the course, said the site is special but the process is flawed.
"I'm seeing, like, dozens of square miles from one spot," Palmer said. "This is a special place." He added that waiving the laws through a budget provision sidesteps public scrutiny.
The House and Senate have each passed their own versions of the closeout budget; the Senate version did not include the golf course amendment. Negotiators are working on a compromise to send to Gov. Maura Healey in the coming weeks. Keenan, who remembers standing on the site as a young aide when the first trucks of Big Dig dirt arrived, said the city should do more homework before committing to a lease that would outlast anyone born today.
"It's a great facility," Keenan said. "But, you know, this [proposed deal] goes out longer than the life expectancy of somebody born today."