Local
Wampanoag Coalition Returns to Court Over Plymouth's Day of Mourning Restrictions
The United American Indians of New England have asked a court to enforce a 1998 agreement after Plymouth again demanded permits and insurance for the National Day of Mourning, prompting the group to stop complying with the deal.
PLYMOUTH â A Native American coalition is asking a court to force the town to honor a decades-old agreement governing the National Day of Mourning, accusing local officials of again imposing permit and insurance requirements that threaten the annual gathering on Coles Hill.
The United American Indians of New England (UAINE) filed court documents Monday alleging that Plymouth violated a 1998 agreement that affirmed the group's right to hold the event, which has been observed on Thanksgiving since 1970 to confront the genocide and discrimination that followed the 1621 feast. The group's members voted Nov. 10 to stop complying with the agreement, according to the filings, a decision made during an executive session first reported by the Plymouth Independent.
At the heart of the dispute is the town's insistence that UAINE obtain permits and liability insurance before Plymouth will erect a stage on Coles Hill. Town attorneys previously argued that the 1998 pact cannot dictate event details indefinitely and sought to amend it. Last November, with the march and holiday just two days away, the two sides reached a settlement allowing the event to proceed. But organizers say the town has since revived the same requirements.
"Plymouth clearly cares more about preserving the 'America's Hometown' fantasy it has created for itself than it cares about freedom of speech or meeting its obligations to UAINE under the 1998 agreement," Kisha James, co-leader of UAINE and a member of the Wampanoag Tribe of Gay Head (Aquinnah), said in a statement.
James's reference was to the town's annual "America's Hometown Thanksgiving Parade," held the Saturday before Thanksgiving. Other Wampanoag members and allies, including descendants of colonists, voiced outrage over the requirements and the executive-session vote at a meeting Tuesday night.
Select Board Chair Deb Iaquinto said Tuesday that the town supports the Day of Mourning and has been negotiating with organizers for months. "It makes us look like the bad guys, but we require every other group to provide insurance," Iaquinto told the Plymouth Independent. "The town is between a rock and a hard place." Select Board members and Town Manager Derek Brindisi did not respond to multiple requests for comment.
In the court filings, UAINE says the town has repeatedly shifted its rationale for opposing the agreement, most recently asserting that Coles Hill is state property. The state Department of Conservation and Recreation, which owns the land, told the town and organizers on Nov. 5 that it had no objection to the event or to the town erecting a stage, according to the filings. DCR did not respond to emailed questions Wednesday.
The 1998 agreement was forged after a violent clash with police a year earlier, when authorities tried to stop the march. It confirmed that UAINE could continue holding the event every year. The current standoff leaves organizers barely a week to reach a resolution before this year's National Day of Mourning.
For Plymouth, the case raises questions about whose history the town chooses to elevate as it markets itself as "America's Hometown" â and whether a local government can use permitting rules to constrain a long-standing act of Indigenous remembrance and dissent.