Saturday, November 21, 2026·Focal News

The Boston Focal

Boston's independent voice

Local

Stoughton's First Female Police Chief Returns to Work After Months on Leave

Police Chief Donna McNamara, sidelined since July amid a dispute with the town manager, will return Monday following the federal conviction of a former detective in the Sandra Birchmore case.

Stoughton's First Female Police Chief Returns to Work After Months on Leave

STOUGHTON — Police Chief Donna McNamara will return to work Monday morning, her lawyer said Friday, ending a months-long standoff that began when she accused Town Manager Thomas J. Calter of trying to force her out.

McNamara, the town's first female police chief, had been away from her post since July. The Select Board placed both McNamara and Calter on paid administrative leave and ordered an independent investigation into the dispute.

The reinstatement comes as the department reckons with the fallout from the federal trial of former Stoughton detective Matthew Farwell, who was convicted last week of killing Sandra Birchmore. McNamara had ordered an internal investigation that is credited with prompting the FBI to examine Birchmore's death.

That inquiry put McNamara at odds with powerful interests inside and outside the department, and her absence left the town without its top law enforcement official during one of the most scrutinized periods in its history.

Details of the independent investigation's findings were not immediately available Friday. It was not clear whether the probe cleared McNamara of any wrongdoing or whether Calter faces any consequences.

For residents, the chief's return closes a chapter of uncertainty at the department. McNamara is expected back at headquarters Monday morning.

More from The Boston Focal