Thursday, November 19, 2026·Focal News

The Boston Focal

Boston's independent voice

Local

Native American Group Sues Plymouth Over Denied Stage for Day of Mourning

United American Indians of New England has asked a judge for a temporary restraining order after the Plymouth Select Board voted not to provide a stage for the annual National Day of Mourning gathering on Cole's Hill, escalating a decades-long legal fight over the Thanksgiving ceremony.

Native American Group Sues Plymouth Over Denied Stage for Day of Mourning

A Native American advocacy group is taking the town of Plymouth back to court, accusing local officials of blocking the stage it needs for its annual National Day of Mourning gathering on Thanksgiving.

United American Indians of New England, or UAINE, filed a request Monday for a temporary restraining order, saying the town has refused to provide a stage on Cole's Hill, where the group has held its ceremony for decades. According to the filing, UAINE was told the Plymouth Select Board voted last week not to facilitate a stage or an alternative.

A 2025 court order in the long-running litigation requires a stage to be erected on Cole's Hill for the ceremony. The two sides had been scheduled for a hearing this month, but it was postponed twice — once at their joint request and once by the court. The next hearing is now set for Dec. 15 before Judge Joseph Leighton.

"We believe they are throwing up roadblocks because they don't want the tourists to see or hear Native Americans who are speaking about the true history of the Pilgrim invasion and resulting land theft and genocide of Wampanoag and other Native peoples," UAINE co-leader Mahtowin Munro said in a news release.

Plymouth officials pushed back Wednesday, saying the town supports free assembly and has worked productively with UAINE on nearly every aspect of the event. In a statement, the town said the stage location sits on state property and that it has "offered multiple alternatives for a stage for UAINE's consideration," which the organization has not accepted.

"The Town has gone above and beyond to accommodate UAINE's event, including facilitating accessible parking, assisting Elders, identifying locations for meals and extended observances, and coordinating with Police and Fire officials," the statement said. "These efforts reflect a genuine commitment to the event."

The National Day of Mourning is held each Thanksgiving to reflect on the devastation European settlement brought to Native American communities. Last year's gathering in Plymouth drew more than 1,000 people, according to The Boston Globe.

"The pilgrims are not ancient history, and we cannot allow their crimes to be sanitized and forgotten," UAINE co-leader Kisha James told the newspaper. "That is why, year after year, we have gathered on this hill to tear down the Thanksgiving mythology."

The dispute is the latest chapter in litigation over the ceremony that dates back decades. Leighton's order last year, issued the day before Thanksgiving, required that a stage be allowed for the 2025 ceremony and that UAINE release the town from liability tied to its use.

With Thanksgiving less than two weeks away, the Dec. 15 hearing date falls after the holiday, leaving the fate of this year's stage — and the gathering itself — uncertain.

More from The Boston Focal