Local
Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court to Hear Lindsay Clancy Double Jeopardy Appeal in January
The full Supreme Judicial Court will hear oral arguments in January on whether retrying Lindsay Clancy for the 2023 deaths of her three children violates double jeopardy protections, months before her March 29 retrial in Plymouth Superior Court.
The Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court will hear oral arguments in January on a defense motion to dismiss the murder case against Lindsay Clancy, setting up a high-stakes legal showdown months before her scheduled retrial.
Justice Elizabeth Dewar wrote that all seven justices should review the motion filed by Clancy's attorney, which argues that a second trial would violate her constitutional protection against double jeopardy. Both sides have until next month to file legal briefs, and oral arguments are expected in January â well ahead of the March 29 retrial date set this week by Plymouth Superior Court Judge William Sullivan.
Clancy's attorneys contend that the trial judge should have done more to investigate notes from the jury foreperson indicating that one juror would not follow instructions on reasonable doubt. The jury deadlocked in September after one of the 12 deliberating jurors did not agree that Clancy was not criminally responsible for the deaths of her children.
Sullivan declared a mistrial after jurors reported they could not reach a unanimous verdict on whether Clancy should be convicted of first-degree murder or acquitted because of mental illness.
"This appeal will address whether a defendant has a double jeopardy clause protection against facing the perils and burdens of a second trial when, in the prior trial, a trial court declines to question jurors who have disclosed that one of their members was unable to follow and apply the law as to an issue as pivotal as the requirement of proof beyond a reasonable doubt," Clancy's attorney Martin Weinberg said in an emailed statement.
Prosecutors countered that Sullivan properly instructed the jury on reasonable doubt without coercing its members and that the mistrial was appropriate.
"The judge here took every possible tack to address the foreperson's notes while avoiding the risk of pressuring the dissenting juror or exposing the jury's private deliberations," assistant Plymouth County district attorney Melissa Johnsen wrote in the commonwealth's filing to the high court.
Clancy's attorneys have said she killed her three children â 5-year-old Cora, 3-year-old Dawson and 8-month-old Callan â in their Duxbury home in 2023. They argue she should not be held criminally responsible because of postpartum psychosis.
Prosecutors noted that the high court previously denied a defense request to stay the proceedings before the mistrial was declared. They argue that dismissing the case "would altogether extinguish the Commonwealth's ability to honor the rights of Cora, Dawson, and Callan Clancy."
A status hearing is scheduled for next month. The appeal will be closely watched in Plymouth County and beyond, touching on questions of mental health, jury instructions and the limits of double jeopardy protections in cases involving deeply contested questions of criminal responsibility.