Politics
Supreme Court Declines Maryland Gun Case, Upholds Sensitive Places Law
The U.S. Supreme Court refused Monday to hear a challenge to Maryland's 2023 law restricting firearms in sensitive places like parks, transit and schools, leaving the law in place. Attorney General Anthony Brown called it a public safety victory, while gun-rights groups vowed to keep fighting.
The U.S. Supreme Court on Monday declined to take up a challenge to Maryland's restrictions on carrying firearms in "sensitive places" such as state parks, amusement parks and mass transit, leaving a lower court ruling in place and keeping the 2023 law intact.
The court rejected an appeal by gun-rights groups of a January decision by the 4th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in Novotny v. Moore, which upheld most of the law. The action means Maryland's location-specific limits on carrying weapons will remain in effect.
In a separate statement on the case, Justice Clarence Thomas said he was "skeptical" that each part of the Maryland law is consistent with Second Amendment principles. But Thomas said he agreed with the decision to reject the case because "the breadth of petitioners' challenge would complicate our review."
Maryland Attorney General Anthony Brown, whose office defended the law, called the court's rejection "a clear victory for public safety in our state."
"Marylanders should never have to choose between participating in everyday life and feeling safe from gun violence," Brown said in a statement released Tuesday. "Maryland's sensitive places laws keep firearms out of hospitals, public transit, and State parks, where children and families gather, work, and play."
Gun-rights groups expressed disappointment. Bill Sack, senior director of legal operations at the Second Amendment Foundation, which was among the petitioners, said his organization was "disappointed" and argued that Maryland "has extinguished the Second Amendment rights of its residents" by creating "multiple categories of so-called sensitive places."
"We are encouraged, however, with Justice Thomas' statement in which he casts serious doubt as to the constitutionality of laws like Maryland's," Sack wrote.
The foundation has a narrower case pending before the Supreme Court focused on New York's sensitive places carry ban in public parks, Sack noted.
"We are hopeful the Court takes a very hard look at that case and elects to restore the right to carry for the Americans all over the country that are subject to these unconstitutional laws," Sack wrote.
Another petitioner, Maryland Shall Issue, also criticized the court's rejection.
"The Court's order is, of course, a disappointment, but we will continue to press appropriate challenges to misguided legislation that is designed for no other reason than to eviscerate the general right to publicly carry arms for self-defense," the group said in a statement.
Some of Maryland's location-specific constraints on carrying weapons are long-standing, but others were added or amended by the General Assembly in the 2023 law. Those include restrictions on properties hosting children and vulnerable people, such as daycare facilities, schools and hospitals, as well as government buildings and special event and entertainment areas.
The high court's decision came one week after a U.S. District Court judge in Maryland upheld a similar law from Montgomery County, dismissing a challenge filed by the U.S. Justice Department.