Friday, November 20, 2026·Focal News

The Atlanta Focal

Atlanta's independent voice

Local

Thomas County Jury Awards $164M to Georgia Couple in Birth Injury Case

A Thomas County jury awarded more than $164 million to Ben and Charis Lirette, whose son Grayson suffered severe and permanent birth injuries. The verdict against Dr. Joseph Novak and Shaw Center for Women's Health is believed to be the largest medical malpractice verdict in Georgia history.

Thomas County Jury Awards $164M to Georgia Couple in Birth Injury Case

A Thomas County jury on Wednesday awarded more than $164 million to a South Georgia couple who alleged that a doctor's negligence caused their son's severe and permanent birth injuries, a verdict their attorneys believe is the largest medical malpractice award in Georgia history and the fourth largest of its kind in the nation.

The $164,586,856 verdict came against Thomas County obstetrician-gynecologist Joseph Novak and his employer, Shaw Center for Women's Health, in a case filed in 2018 by Ben and Charis Lirette on behalf of their son, Grayson, who turns 10 in January. It was the third trial in the long-running litigation.

Novak and the Thomasville health center denied wrongdoing throughout the proceedings. Their lawyers did not respond Thursday to questions about the case.

Charis Lirette told reporters that she and her husband have relied on their faith to endure the yearslong legal battle. She said the family hopes the verdict will help provide the resources needed to care for Grayson, who she said suffered catastrophic brain damage and cannot walk or eat on his own.

"He is our life," she said. "We finally have what we need for him."

The Lirettes alleged that Novak failed to properly monitor the pregnancy and communicate concerns about the baby's condition before delivery, and that he increased risks by ordering the use of a labor-inducing drug despite warning signs. According to the allegations, the standard of care required that the baby be delivered by cesarean section, but Novak instead attempted a vaginal delivery.

Attorneys for the family argued that Novak and Shaw Center failed to meet reasonable standards of care and that the defendants were responsible for the injuries. The defense contended that the doctor provided appropriate care and that the injuries were not the result of negligence.

The case had a difficult procedural history. The first trial ended in a mistrial in 2023, and a second trial in 2025 was also declared a mistrial after jurors deadlocked. A judge later ordered a third trial, which concluded this week.

Jurors awarded $51 million for Grayson's pain and suffering, $4.31 million for lost earning capacity, and $1.1 million for medical expenses, among other damages, according to the family's legal team.

Attorney Adam Malone, who represented the Lirettes along with Nelson Tyrone and others, said the verdict sends a message about accountability. "This is a story that needed to be told," Malone said. "The jury's verdict shows that justice is available in Thomas County."

Tyrone said the family's ordeal has been compounded by the repeated trials. "They've been through this three times," he said. "They never gave up because they knew their son needed them."

The verdict is expected to face post-trial motions and possible appeal. Legal experts say large medical malpractice awards in Georgia are often reduced or overturned on appeal, but the Lirettes' attorneys said they are confident the verdict will withstand scrutiny.

The case has drawn attention to the challenges families face in holding medical providers accountable, particularly in rural areas where access to specialized care is limited. It also comes as state lawmakers continue to debate tort reform measures that would cap damages in medical malpractice cases, a proposal critics say would harm patients' ability to seek justice.

For the Lirettes, the verdict represents a measure of closure after nearly a decade of litigation. Charis Lirette said the family remains focused on Grayson's care and on giving him as normal a life as possible.

"We take it one day at a time," she said. "We are grateful for the support we've received from our community and our faith."

More from The Atlanta Focal